From ‘Fight the Power’ to ‘Obey the Power’

Hip-Hopcrisy, COVID, and the illusion of Black rebellion in the age of Democratic control.

From ‘Fight the Power’ to ‘Obey the Power’

For decades, Black America’s cultural identity has been wrapped in the language of defiance. “Fight the Power” wasn’t just a Public Enemy anthem; it was a declaration. Hip-hop videos, protest chants, and political speeches all carried the same message: we will not bow to authority, especially not the authority we distrust.

But when COVID hit, the rebellion was revealed for what it was: branding, not backbone.

By 2025, the verdict is in:

• Masks didn’t stop the spread.

• Lockdowns destroyed more lives than they saved.

• Vaccines carried real risks, downplayed or ignored by the very institutions that told us to “trust the science.”

Yet the same communities that claimed to distrust “the system” were among the first to comply with its every command. The same rappers who once shouted “F the Police” took to Instagram to tell their fans to “mask up” and “get your shot.” The same political voices that preached about resisting oppression praised government lockdown orders that shuttered Black-owned businesses at record rates.

This isn’t just a story about hypocrisy; it’s a case study in how a political machine can take a culture built on rebellion and turn it into an obedient arm of the state almost overnight.

The Collapse of the Rebellion Myth

Black America has long projected an image of defiance against authority, especially in music, activism, and political rhetoric. That posture has been reinforced for decades in the lyrics of N.W.A.’s “F*** Tha Police,” in the raised fists at rallies, and in the insistence that government institutions could not be trusted.

COVID-19 exposed just how fragile that posture was.

When the crisis hit in 2020, the mask became more than a public health symbol; it became a political uniform. Governors and mayors, almost all from the Democrat Party in major Black population centers, imposed rules that devastated schools, closed churches, and put small businesses under. The same voices that once accused the government of being corrupt and oppressive were suddenly its most loyal enforcers.

By 2025, the record is clear. The CDC now admits masks did little to halt transmission. Studies show lockdowns had minimal effect on COVID mortality but catastrophic effects on education and local economies. Vaccine injury data, once dismissed, has entered mainstream reporting. And the communities that complied the fastest and the hardest, including large segments of Black America, paid the steepest price in lost income, lost education, and lost trust.

The collapse of the rebellion myth wasn’t a slow erosion. It happened in real time, and it revealed that much of what passed for resistance was only ever performance.

How Compliance Was Built

The ease with which much of Black America accepted the official COVID narrative was not an accident. It was the product of decades of political conditioning.

For generations, the Democrat Party has positioned itself as the defender against an endless list of crises. Each election cycle is framed as a battle against forces that threaten to drag the Black community backward, whether those forces are described as racist Republicans, corporate greed, or vague “right-wing extremists.” When COVID arrived, it was presented as yet another existential threat, and the solution, according to the same political establishment, was total compliance with government mandates.

The party’s influence in Black communities is reinforced through trusted messengers. Local pastors, activist groups, and celebrities who had long aligned themselves with Democrat politics became the front line of persuasion. In city after city, it was these voices telling people to “trust the science” and follow every directive without question.

The message was simple: good citizens wear masks, get vaccinated, stay home, and report those who refuse. In this climate, skepticism was equated with selfishness or even betrayal. The same people who once warned about “the system” suddenly became its most loyal enforcers.

The irony is hard to miss. The party that once defended slavery and built the legal structure of segregation now maintains its grip through a different form of control. The chains are no longer iron. They are mental, forged through fear, dependence, and the promise of protection, protection that too often comes at the cost of personal freedom and economic opportunity.

By the time the mandates were in place, resistance within these communities was minimal. Compliance had been framed not only as a civic duty, but as a moral badge of honor. And once morality is defined by obedience, questioning authority becomes far more difficult.

The Democratic Party has never freed Black America. It simply replaced physical chains with mental ones.

The Cultural About-Face

Before COVID (Pre-2020)

For decades, Black American cultural identity, particularly in urban centers, had been packaged and sold as resistance. From the political militancy of the 1960s to the lyrical rebellion of late-80s hip-hop, the posture was consistent: the system could not be trusted, and those in power were presumed guilty until proven otherwise.

The music reflected it. In 1988, N.W.A.’s “F*** tha Police” became an anthem of defiance, bluntly declaring war on law enforcement and by extension, the government’s authority. Public Enemy’s “Fight the Power” (1989) went further, weaving historical grievances into a message of total non-cooperation with the establishment. These weren’t just songs; they were political manifestos set to a beat.

The numbers reinforced the sentiment. Gallup polls from the 1990s and early 2000s consistently showed Black Americans expressing far lower levels of trust in the federal government than White Americans. A 2019 Pew Research survey found that only 20% of Black respondents said they trusted the federal government “most of the time,” compared to 36% of Whites.

Law enforcement trust was even lower. A 2016 Gallup poll conducted after multiple high-profile police shootings found that just 30% of Black Americans expressed “a great deal” or “quite a lot” of confidence in police, compared to 57% of Whites. That distrust was not only statistical, it was cultural currency. Wearing it was part of belonging.

The political rhetoric matched the music. Activists spoke of systemic oppression as a constant, unchanging force. Politicians on the left reinforced it, using phrases like “the system is stacked against you” to both describe and justify their own role as protectors.

The point wasn’t subtle: defiance was a virtue, compliance was betrayal, and anyone who followed government orders without question was a sellout.

History will not remember how loudly you rapped about defiance. It will remember how quickly you obeyed.

During COVID (2020–2022)

That posture evaporated almost overnight. The same community leaders and cultural icons who had built careers on distrusting the establishment suddenly became the loudest voices telling their audiences to obey it. The rebellion that once filled albums and rallies was replaced with a chorus of “trust the science” and “mask up,” delivered by the very people who once warned about government lies.

Compliance was reframed as a moral obligation, a litmus test for whether you genuinely cared about “the community.” Refusing was painted as selfish and dangerous, often with the same moral shaming tactics that the community had historically condemned when used against them.

• Viola Davis appeared in national PSAs urging mask-wearing specifically among Black Americans, using emotional appeals and family-focused messaging.

• Cardi B embraced mask culture through pop-culture riffs, even approving a “WAP: Wear a Mask Please” parody poster, leveraging her platform to push CDC talking points.

• Dapper Dan, the Harlem fashion legend, publicly got vaccinated on camera while invoking Tuskegee and Henrietta Lacks, only to declare it was time to “move forward” and trust the system.

• Hip Hop Public Health, co-founded by Darryl “DMC” McDaniels, released “Behind the Mask,” a rap music video designed as a COVID PSA for Black and Latin youth.

• LeBron James, after initial hesitance, became a vocal supporter of masking and adherence to NBA COVID protocols, effectively normalizing compliance for millions of fans.

What had once been a soundtrack of defiance was rebranded into jingles for obedience. Celebrities broadcast their vaccine selfies, posted their CDC cards, and called out anyone questioning mandates, turning what had been a culture of skepticism into one of public shaming for dissent.

After COVID (2023–2025)

When the dust settled, the data stripped away the moral high ground that compliance advocates had claimed. A 2023 Cochrane review concluded that mask mandates had little to no measurable effect on community spread. NAEP test scores showed the most significant single-year drop in reading and math for Black students ever recorded. CDC data confirmed that lockdown-driven unemployment hit Black-owned businesses harder than any other demographic, with many never reopening.

Yet even as most of America abandoned the theater of COVID by mid-2023, ditching masks, ignoring distancing, and rejecting further boosters, many Black communities remained outwardly compliant. In cities like New York, Philadelphia, and Washington, D.C., it was still common in 2024 to see masked bus riders, retail workers, and grocery store clerks in predominantly Black neighborhoods.

Surveys from late 2023 showed that Black Americans continued to wear masks in public at nearly twice the rate of White Americans, and booster uptake among vaccinated Black adults remained well above the national average into 2024. In many Democrat-run cities, local leaders still promoted mask use “as a sign of community care,” even in the absence of mandates.

For some, it was political alignment. For others, it was cultural inertia. Once compliance had been framed as a badge of virtue, abandoning it meant admitting that the rebellion had been an act all along. While the rest of the country had moved on, parts of Black America were still performing obedience like it was 2021, holding onto a narrative that even the political class had stopped pretending to believe.

The Mask as Muzzle

Literal: a piece of cloth over the face that science later admitted had minimal public health benefit.

Symbolic: a visible badge of loyalty to state narratives.

In early 2020, mask mandates were presented as “temporary measures” to slow the spread. Yet even by mid-2021, CDC data and peer-reviewed studies were already showing that cloth masks, the kind most people wore, provided little to no protection in community settings. A 2023 Cochrane review, which examined dozens of studies, concluded that mask mandates had no statistically significant impact on the spread of respiratory viruses.

Despite this, the mask took on a life of its own in Black communities, especially in Democrat-run urban areas. In cities like New York and Philadelphia, mask use remained high in majority-Black neighborhoods well into 2024, long after mandates were lifted. A Pew Research survey in September 2023 found that 47% of Black adults were still wearing masks in public regularly, compared to 24% of White adults. Among those vaccinated, the rates were even higher.

The mask had become more than a health measure; it became a cultural signal. In the same way that political buttons or protest T-shirts advertise allegiance, the mask became a badge of compliance. Wearing it meant you were “responsible,” “caring,” and “informed”, even if the science no longer supported its use.

The irony is that these same communities once rejected any dress code imposed by the state. In the 1990s, sagging pants and gang colors were defended as expressions of identity, and attempts to regulate them were seen as oppression. But during COVID, the same people who scoffed at dress codes embraced a government-imposed facial dress code without a whisper of defiance.

And in workplaces, particularly in service and retail jobs where Black workers are overrepresented, the mask became a muzzle in more ways than one. While office workers in white-collar settings ditched masks early, grocery clerks, bus drivers, and warehouse employees, many of them Black, were still required to wear them. This wasn’t “shared sacrifice.” It was a visible hierarchy of who could breathe freely and who could not.

Even now, scattered holdouts cling to the mask as a comfort object, much like a child clutches a blanket. The message it sends is less about safety and more about submission, a public declaration that you will follow orders, no matter how outdated or unfounded they have become.

A mask is not just a cloth over the mouth. It’s a cloth over the mind when worn for political obedience, not health.

Selective Mistrust

Black America has every historical reason to be suspicious of government and medical authority. The Tuskegee Syphilis Experiment, where 600 Black men were deceived and denied treatment from 1932 to 1972 so bureaucrats could “study” them, is not distant history. Henrietta Lacks’ cells were taken without consent in 1951 and exploited for decades without her family’s knowledge. These stories have been told for generations as proof that the system lies, exploits, and discards Black lives.

And yet, when COVID hit, that skepticism vanished almost overnight. Not because the system suddenly became trustworthy, but because the orders came from the Democrat Party.

You cannot be both the resistance and the enforcers of the very system you claim to oppose.

For most of American history, the Democrat Party’s relationship with Black America was about control. Before the 1960s, that control came through brute force: slavery, Black Codes, and Jim Crow laws, all enforced by Democrat power in the South. After the civil rights era, the method changed, but the goal did not. Physical chains were replaced with political ones. By branding itself as the champion of civil rights, the Democrat Party secured near-total Black electoral loyalty. In return, it delivered dependency in the form of welfare policies that fractured family structures, urban governance that kept schools failing and neighborhoods dangerous, and a political machine that treated Black votes as guaranteed property.

COVID was simply the latest chapter in that same story: control repackaged as “protection.” And millions of Black Americans complied without question, subservient to their Democrat masters, even when the policies harmed them most.

The numbers prove how deep that conditioning runs.

• Pew, April 2021: 86 percent of Black Democrats said they trusted the CDC a great deal or a fair amount, the highest trust level of any racial or partisan group.

• KFF, mid-2021: Black Democrats were nearly twice as likely as White Republicans to believe the federal government was “doing enough” to protect people from COVID.

• Gallup, 2020–2021: Trust in the federal government among Black Americans spiked after the White House changed hands in 2021, despite the virus, vaccines, and policies being essentially the same.

Behavior followed the polling. Early 2021 surveys showed the highest mask adherence among Black Americans in major metros, often above 80 percent. This compliance stayed high well into 2023 and even 2024, long after much of the country had moved on.

Mistrust was never a principle. It was a partisan weapon pointed at Republicans, holstered for Democrats.

The Hypocrisy Problem

Conservative Blacks are often accused of “bowing to Republicans” simply for voting their convictions. Yet the same people making those accusations had no problem falling in line when their Democrat masters told them to.

Look at the treatment of figures like Clarence Thomas, Candace Owens, and Larry Elder. Thomas has been called an “Uncle Tom” for decades simply because his judicial philosophy does not align with the Democratic Party. Owens was branded a “coon” and “sellout” for questioning COVID mandates and vaccine safety. Elder, during his 2021 run for California governor, was smeared as the “Black face of white supremacy” by the Los Angeles Times. These were not fringe attacks. They came from within the Black community, amplified by media outlets that claim to speak for Black America.

Now compare that to the pass given to high-profile Black Democrats who pushed the most destructive COVID policies. Stacey Abrams was photographed maskless in a room full of masked children, yet her defenders insisted critics were being “petty.” Chicago’s Lori Lightfoot enforced some of the harshest lockdowns in the country while ignoring her own rules to get a haircut. Black media voices like Joy Reid and Don Lemon relentlessly pushed vaccine compliance and vilified dissenters, yet the very people who once said “question authority” never questioned them.

They accepted, and even applauded, policies that closed Black-owned businesses at twice the national rate. They cheered for school shutdowns that widened the already massive achievement gap for Black students, erasing decades of educational progress. They shamed neighbors for questioning a vaccine rollout later proven to carry real risks, especially for people with higher rates of obesity, hypertension, and diabetes.

The rhetoric remained, “Never trust the system.” The reality was, “Yes, sir. I’ll mask, I’ll vax, and I’ll report anyone who doesn’t.”

It wasn’t rebellion. It was selective rebellion. Resistance only mattered when the orders came from the political party they opposed. When the orders came from their own side, compliance was recast as “doing the right thing.”

This wasn’t a one-off. It revealed a cultural reflex that had been decades in the making, where political allegiance overrides lived experience, historical memory, and self-preservation. COVID did not create this hypocrisy. It exposed it in full daylight.

Hip-Hopcrisy: From 'Fight the Power' to 'Obey the Power'

Hip-hop was born out of rebellion. In the 1980s, groups like Public Enemy, KRS-One, and N.W.A. built their reputations on defying authority, calling out government corruption, and warning their audience not to trust the system. That was the public face of the movement, a voice for the voiceless, a soundtrack for resistance.

By the 1990s, the industry had shifted. Corporate labels, often owned and operated by executives far removed from the communities they profited from, realized there was more money in promoting self-destruction than in promoting self-determination. Lyrical content moved away from political awareness and toward gang violence, drug use, and sexual exploitation. The same artists who once said “Fight the Power” were replaced or rebranded to glorify a lifestyle that conveniently kept their audience distracted, demoralized, and dependent.

By the time COVID hit, the hip-hop industry was already in the hands of a few major conglomerates. Those conglomerates had business ties, sponsorship deals, and media relationships that aligned with the very political establishment hip-hop once claimed to resist. So when mask mandates, lockdowns, and vaccines became the new “virtues,” the industry’s most visible artists became spokespeople for the state.

Rappers like Juvenile remixed “Back That Azz Up” into “Vax That Thang Up” to promote COVID shots. Meek Mill, once vocal about government corruption in the justice system, urged fans to “mask up” and “listen to the doctors” without questioning the same institutions that had failed his community for decades. Even Jay-Z and Beyoncé, who built their empires on a brand of cultural pride and empowerment, appeared in vaccine PSAs and partnered with organizations pushing compliance.

The hypocrisy was glaring. The same voices that told young Black men not to trust the police now told them to obey the CDC. The same industry that once celebrated resistance to authority now mocked and marginalized anyone who resisted COVID policies.

This was not an organic shift. It was a demonstration of who really controlled the cultural narrative. Hip-hop rebellion had always been allowed only within the boundaries set by its corporate gatekeepers. When those gatekeepers decided that the new profitable message was obedience, the so-called rebels fell in line.

And the audience followed. Not because the facts supported it, but because the people they had been conditioned to trust, their cultural icons, told them compliance was the new form of pride.

Real rebellion isn’t measured in lyrics or hashtags. It’s measured in the willingness to defy power even when that power wears your party’s colors.

The Next Test

The lesson of COVID was never just about masks, vaccines, or lockdowns. It was about the danger of mistaking branding for backbone. For years, Black America sold an image of defiance, yet when the orders came from their political side, that defiance vanished. COVID was a loyalty test, and too many failed it, not to the enemy they claimed to oppose, but to the power they had already pledged to serve.

The Democratic Party didn’t have to convince anyone. They already owned the channels of influence, politicians, media, schools, and celebrities who could flip rebellion into obedience almost overnight. That is Hip-Hopcrisy in action: the same voices that once said “fight the power” telling people to “obey the power” as long as it wore a blue tie.

But there are signs the spell is weakening. In 2024, Donald Trump earned roughly 15 percent of the Black vote, up from just 8 percent in 2020. Among Black men, support climbed past 20 percent, the highest share for a Republican in decades. These numbers may not sound revolutionary, but in the razor-thin margins of American presidential elections, they are seismic. Even a modest realignment could shatter the Democratic Party’s lock on national power.

This is not yet a political revolution, but it is a crack in the wall. A shift from 90–95 percent Democrat loyalty to even a 50/50 split would force both parties to compete for Black votes instead of one taking them for granted and the other writing them off. Competition breeds accountability; blind loyalty breeds complacency.

If 15% of Black voters can see through the Democratic Party’s game, imagine what happens when that number becomes 50.

The same party that once held Black bodies in physical bondage now keeps their minds in political chains. The next crisis will come. The question is whether more will break free or, once again, step willingly back onto the plantation for the comfort of being told what to do.

COVID didn’t kill the spirit of ‘Fight the Power.’ It revealed it was never there to begin with.

---

Arnell’s Substack is a reader-supported publication. I don’t run ads. I don’t hide my work behind paywalls. Everything I write is for everyone, especially the people no one else will speak for.

If you value this work, you can help keep it going:

• Become a Paid Subscriber: https://mrchr.is/help

• Join The Resistance Core (Founding Member): https://mrchr.is/resist

• Buy Me a Coffee: https://mrchr.is/give

Sharing and restacking also helps more than you know.